Economics Matters — Blog/Podcast/Financial Riddler/MaxiFi Puzzler
Sign up at larrykotlikoff.substack.com for a free short-term subscription. I’ll immediately make it a free lifetime subscription. Also, pls sign up kids, parents, … — everyone you know.
Paid subscriptions come with a monthly Q&A session via Substack Live. I’ll email you the day and time. Submit questions on anything and everything via chat. I’ll be live.
Subscribe as a Founding Member - Please help me continue providing high-level economics content and cover the significant podcast costs. Subscribers receive a free, one-hour financial therapy session (kotlikoff@gmail.com) and full access to my monthly live Q&As.
Teaching Financial Literacy/Economics? Email me for free MaxiFi licenses for your students and a free PRO license for yourself. kotlikoff@gmail.com
Speaking Inquiries — visit www.chartwellspeakers.com
Disclaimer: All opinions expressed in Economics Matters’ posts are those of the authors and guests. They are not the opinions of Boston University or Economic Security Planning, Inc.
To Dream the American Dream
On January 24, 2013, four days after President Obama’s second inauguration, I participated in a debate at the Oxford Union — a debate on the vitality and viability of the American Dream.
The Union is a debating society established by Oxford University students in 1823. Over the years, the Union has held over 4,000 debates. Five future British Prime Ministers, four American Presidents, including President Kennedy, as well as Malcolm X, Nelson Mandela, Mother Teresa, the Dalai Lama, and other notables have either participated in debates or addressed the Union. My favorite polite argument is the 1965 debate between James Baldwin and William Buckley.
Given the Union’s list of prodigious former speakers, imagine my surprise and trepidation at being asked by the Union to debate a question far beyond the scope of an economist — the continued relevance of the American Dream.
The Union’s Question
Did the American Dream still exist? Was America still the land of freedom, democracy, decency, the rule of law, science, opportunity, human rights, civil rights, prosperity, fiscal responsibility? Was it still the trusted ally — the New World that had come to the rescue of the Old — in two bloody world wars to let freedom ring?
Or was it the land of the rich and powerful, the racist, the fascist, the intolerant, the slave owner, the exterminator of Native Americans, the bigot, the lyncher, the crooked politician, the practitioner of fiscal child abuse, the gunslinger, the mobster, the bad cop, the imperialist, the police state, and more?
The American Dream was in serious enough danger in 2013. Today, it’s on life support, run by a President who idolizes himself, craves power, money, and adulation beyond all measure, has unleashed jackbooted soldiers to shoot innocent American citizens, not to mention immigrants, legal and illegal, in the streets, vilifies immigrants (as if he and his arrived with Leif Erikson), openly conspires to steal the next election, actively suppresses the free press, consorts with our enemies while betraying our allies, and has, with a few important exceptions, delivered the administration of our county to morons and incompetents. Yet, to be fair, President Trump is also trying to protect us, albeit incompetently, from Iran — a nation whose raison d’être appears to be our nation’s utter destruction.
The Ask
The Union asked me to argue for the Nays — that we could no longer dream the American Dream. That made me uncomfortable. It felt unpatriotic to disparage my own country in a foreign land. Moreover, I had never participated in a formal debate.
What were the rules?
I accepted the assignment after realizing I could provide hope for the Dream’s rebirth in the course of describing its demise. But the day before the debate, I was asked to switch sides. Someone on the Yeas’ side couldn’t stomach standing up for America.
“Would you kindly be a yeah for the Yeas?”
“Yes, certainly, thank you!”
My Part in the Debate
Please click the button below to see/hear what I said. I must confess, when I rose to speak, I had literally no idea what would come out of my mouth. But words emerged, albeit with a Camden, NJ accent. Still, these words may provide some hope in these troubled days.


I supported your plan ( actually I supported you for POTUS or VP) on universal health coverage both then and now. Unfortunately we are going backwards.
The Trump administration has attacked Medicaid and Mediacare to pay for the OBBB.
Instead of fixing the entire system, the Trump and his cronies react to their worst instincts. Let the least fortunate among us die.
You have made more than ample, common sense and financially feasible arguments over many, many years, for repair of both the Social Security and Health Care delivery promises of America.
Over that time we may not have killed the American "dream", but we have become a completely different nation. We are headed down a path to a fascist outcome.
If people do not see Larry's carefully crafted policy proposals as a solution to put us back on track for the fundamental underpinnings of a society that can be free from fear, then recognize that it is those "freedoms" which will once allow us to dream, then you can be sure it all ends badly.